Showing posts with label Fear and Horror. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fear and Horror. Show all posts

Saturday, April 20, 2013

The Monster Among us in Psycho


        Psycho, by Alfred Hitchcock, is unquestionably one of the foundational movies in cinema, especially horror. The mystery and repulsion surrounding the character of Norman Bates has entertained for decades. The character of Norman Bates just spawned a completely separate television serious because of this fascination.
          The story in Psycho starts out with the character of Marion Crane, who steals thousands of dollars and runs of to be with her boyfriend. On her way to see him, it rains and she is forced to stop at the Bates Motel, where Norman is the manager. He acts extremely nice and seems very nervous and shy. At this point you like the Norman, he seems innocent and almost child-like. Marion then gets murdered in the hotel shower by what is later thought to be Norman’s mother. As the story progresses and Marion’s sister and boyfriend look for Marion they slowly discover more and more about Norman. In the end, Norman’s psychopathic nature is revealed. He exists in two personalities, himself and his dead mother, who he perceives as jealous and psychotic. The scariest scene is in the end as you finally see him acting out his mother’s personality, saying that she wouldn’t hurt a fly. 
        The scariest part of Psycho is not the violence but the character of Norman Bates. He seems so harmless on the outside, hiding the fact that he is actually deeply disturbed. At first you do not want to believe that he would be capable of that kind of violence since he does seem so innocent. And part of the disturbing part of Norman is that the harmless part of him does exist and is not just a mask. But sometimes his mother takes over and he no longer is harmless. 
        While Noel Carroll would argue that the film is not really horror because it does not have a monster in a true sense, we have already discusses how this definition limits horror to an undesirable degree. For as we talked about, the scariest monsters are not necessarily Bigfoot or Godzilla but the monsters among us. A traditional monster is scary because it is unknown and general powerful, we cannot reason with it or come to understand it. This indeed is scary and what Carroll would argues is the basis for horror. 
        Norman Bates is a monster, but not in the sense that we are used to. To us he is a scarier monster because we implicitly trusted him in the beginning with Marion and he betrayed that trust. He is simultaneously human and inhuman, relatable and repulsive. As he tries to talk to Marion we like him and appreciate him but later when he shows no emotion about the deaths of the people he has killed we are scared because someone who was understandable and normal has become someone who we do not understand. 
         Another factor about why Norman is so scary is that we know he is possible. Most people do not believe things such as Bigfoot or Godzilla really exist or are even possible. People like Norman Bates do exist and live in our society. We may not want to accept this fact or think about it very much, but Psycho forces us to consider it. The whole movie, while not likely, is a possible scenario events which frightens to our core. Most horror films, when we watch them, we may be scared but we do not really believe in their possibility. But this movie presents a completely possible set of events which in my opinion makes it all that much more frightening. 
         Psycho clearly is a horror movie, but a different type of horror. Extremely focused on suspense, the film scares us not because it is a idealistic monster but because Norman Bates is a possible, hidden monster. There is no question that Norman Bates is monstrous but he fools us because that is not all of who he is. The frightening thing is that people like Norman exist and could be disguised among us and this is why Psycho stays with you and scares you.

Friday, April 19, 2013

More Horror for everybody

We have established in our readings and in our screenings that a film's success in capturing our attention (whether this be in comedy, horror, or love and sentimentality) is due to its ability to connect with our emotions. If a film can can somehow arouse our thoughts and feelings, then the audience will have a much easier time experiencing emotion, and thus, a more enjoyable experience. It matters not what this experience is, whether it makes us laugh, cry, or frightened - the emotions are what matter because only they can strike up human feelings. Let us go back to horror.
Carroll has said that we are often attracted by what repulses us. That we are curious about the actions and demeanor of the monster at large. In Open Water, we may categorize "the monster" as the combination of the jellyfish, the sharks, the temperature of the water, etc into the forces of nature, which are typically powerful and very random. Therefore, due to the unpredictable nature of nature itself, it makes sense that horror buffs (or any individual watching, really) in the audience become frightened in the scenes with sea creatures attacking and nipping at the poor divers. We are kept on the edge of our seats, biting nails, because you never know. It is just as likely that a shark will not bite you as it will, if you stop and ponder it. You can take all the precautions you like, but really, a shark will do whatever it wants. It is a force in nature that can not be controlled or predicted. The acts of terror by the ocean predators are random. As there are more and more scenes with the sharks not attacking, we begin to understand that the divers are at the mercy of everything. That is why it is so frightening. Like the couple, the audience has no idea which attack will be the one to end it all. Even the current of the ocean itself seems to put another random spin on the couple's fate. They might wake up and find themselves within a certain distance of a boat or buoy, or in the swimming area of a pool of sharks. It is this randomness of the "nature monster" that produces the terror in the narrative.
We know the ending - its predictable. The process and the journey however, are full of random waves of events. In my opinion, I believe the most frightening (or at least uncomfortable, if you weren't really frightened) was the scene where the boyfriend was fatally bitten by the shark. It wasn't the bite or the tense music leading up to the bite itself that was scary, rather the line he says, something like, "It just occurred to me that we could really be eaten by sharks out here!" While this line might even have a sense of humor to it, it also calls to light the man's acceptance of his fate - that he really has no idea what could happen to them at this point. Everything that happens in the following hours of his life will be acts of the randomness of nature. It is this revelation the man has, his acceptance of his fate, that puts a damper on the story. When even the character himself realizes how screwed he is, you know there is even more to fear!
Carroll says that the objects or horror are fundamentally linked to cognitive interest, specifically curiosity (175). I think that these cognitive interests include thoughts that both the characters and the audience members themselves have together. Both the audience and the shark-bait diver know come to realize that, yes, literally anything could happen at any time. There is no controlling the randomness of nature in the middle of the cold ocean.
We can believe all we want about predicting the behavior of wild animals. But people are malled by their own pets sometimes. How can we ever hope to predict the actions of those swimming around our ankles? Does comfort just bring you closer to something that could always potentially harm you? Can you say that you could trust and predict your kitty's every move? Nature is a scary force of unbelievable power. I think its forces go unnoticed all the time, especially in a day in age when humans always try and control it.
I like this movie - not because it did a good job of predicting what would go on in the ocean waters beneath you. But because it did a good job of rendering nature and its creatures completely random. Never being able to expect what happens next is a powerful element of arousing emotion in any audience - whether you are watching a story of love, humor, or a horror.

Saturday, February 16, 2013

Horror and Belief: Shaping our Perceptions

In the previous class we discussed the aspects of horror movies. We talked about some of the key features that make horror movies what they are, and one of the common ideas that we all presented was the idea that a fictional monster was not the qualifying thing about horror movies. Contrary to what Carroll believes, there are other aspects besides the presence of a monster that can be the focus of a horror movie. This being said, I would like to jump into the idea of realist horror. Cynthia Freeland writes about the topic of realist horror and highlights its relation to Aristotle’s Poetics as well as Plato’s critiques on tragedies. She touches on what I believe Carroll misunderstood, “First, in realist horror like Henry, the monster is a true-to-life rather than supernatural being” (Wartenberg & Curran 262). In the article by Carroll, he seems to disbelieve that a human can be qualified as a monster by definition, and limited the category to only supernatural entities that possess some sort of power. Freeland further defines the term “monster” as a malevolent being with unique but dangerous features. This certainly seems to be a better fit because not every supernatural being is considered a monster (i.e. God, Santa Claus, etc.). A monster seems to be more universally defined as a being which chooses not to be morally righteous. A monster can indeed be supernatural and is often portrayed as such, but in the case of realist horror the monster can just be an average human.

A curious aspect of realist horror is the issue of whether the “monster” is actually choosing his/her/its actions. In movies about psycho slashers or charming murderers, a lot of people like to suggest that the person has some sort of mental illness. Maybe they are schizophrenic, or suffer from some intense and unbearable trauma. This is a defense so that people who watch these films, or hear about similar events in real life, will not be led to believe that such a thing could happen to them, or to anyone for that matter. In this sense, realist horror can be even more terrifying than the classic horror genre in that even if mentally ill, these sorts of humans do exist.

Within the story of The Exorcist you see a little of what I mentioned above. For those who have not seen or heard of the movie, the plot of the movie centers on a single mother, her daughter, and a local priest. The mother is an actress and so she and her adolescent daughter live a relaxed life. It is not explained how, but the daughter eventually becomes possessed by an evil entity (Or maybe multiple ones). The mother eventually seeks the help of the priest after modern medicine has no effect on the girl’s condition. The audience is led to believe with very little doubt that the daughter is possessed, but the doctors in the movie are not quite convinced at first (even after the mother reports the entire bed shaking). This issue of belief seems to play a big part in many horror movies, both within the context of the movie and also in the viewpoint of the audience. The way in which people perceive certain situations affects the classifications that are placed on them. For example, in the movie the doctors firmly believe that the daughter’s symptoms are simply due to physiological and psychological anomalies. Their lack of evidence for her drastic behavioral changes only leads them to believe that there is nothing wrong with the daughter. The mother is not religious, but the overwhelming number of impossible events led her to believe that there is a supernatural presence. If one who does not believe in exorcisms watches this movie, does the movie cease to be a horror film? Or is it through suspension of belief that such people can watch movies like this even though they don’t believe that the certain phenomena can occur? Actually I think the obvious answer is that people suspend their beliefs when watching films so that the movie remains what it is. What about in the case of movies that don’t clearly allude to a certain explanation? For example, Donnie Darko is one such film that the audience can explain in two different ways. There is the psychological explanation and there is also the parallel world explanation. In a nutshell, some people think that because of Donnie Darko’s psychological instability, the entire movie is just his imagination going wild. Others, however, believe that the events in the movie are “real” and that Donnie Darko travels through time at the end of the movie. The explanation that a person chooses affects the way the movie is perceived, either being a movie about time travel or a psychological thriller of sorts. Horror movies have this belief aspect within them as well. Realist horror, even though lacking supernatural beings, contain this too in the way that one perceives the human “monster” and whether we classify the person as crazy or if we see the person as normal but morally corrupt. 

The Orphanage

The Orphanage, created by Guillermo del Toro, is a Spanish film about a family who has moved into an old orphanage. The mother, Laura, grew up at the orphanage until she was adopted, and now she's planning on making it a home for children who have special needs. Her son, Simon, is a young imaginative boy. He often plays with imaginary friend, which becomes important throughout the movie, but seems relatively harmless at the beginning.

Simon eventually meets 6 new friends who play with him in the house. They have a particular game they play, where they each have a treasure. The others steal one child's treasure and leave clues for that child, like a treasure hunt. If you find your treasure, you get a wish. Laura and Simon look for Simon's treasure, and when they find it Laura realizes that Simon has discovered that he is adopted and ill, and this creates tension between the two characters. There is still tension when the children who will be moving in come over for a welcome party. This is the turning point of the movie. Simon and Laura have a fight, because Simon wants to show her "Tomas's little house", and Laura doesn't have time. Laura refuses and leaves Simon in his room to go tend to the party. This is the last time we see Simon alive. Later on during the party, Laura goes to look for Simon. A young boy with a burlap sack over his face pushes her into the bathroom and locks the door.
When Carlos, the father, breaks Laura out of the bathroom, they discover that Simon is missing. The rest of the movie is Laura desperately searching for her son. As the movie progresses, the viewer and Laura discover more and more about the house and the events that occurred after Laura was adopted. 9 months after Simon's disappearance, Laura plays the treasure hunt game...

This movie plays around a lot with the line between what is reality and what is supernatural. Everything that happens in this movie can be explained without the supernatural. That may not be what we are led to believe by the end of the movie, but nothing occurs that would necessitate the supernatural, as long as we allow for the hallucinogenic qualities of desperation and drug overdoses. I find this to be very interesting when considering both Carrol and Freeland's writings on horror. Carrol describes the primary reason that we are attracted to horror is primarily curiosity about the monster. Tomas, the young boy in the burlap sack, is the closest thing this movie has to a monster. The viewer gets engrossed in discovering more about the circumstances behind Tomas' life and death. The image of a child in a burlap sack mask is very disturbing, and at first it seems clear that this is a negative character, and that Tomas can be considered a monster. However, as we learn more about the child, and as we discover the truth behind what's going on, Tomas is humanized. He's just a young boy who had a disfigurement and died early. He commits no crime and the viewer is left just pitying the poor boy. This is where the story blends into realist horror. The film has moments of gruesome spectacle (Tomas' appearance, Benigna's horrific death) that are realistic and disturbing. The music and setting make us worried that there is going to be more of these spectacles, but they remain few and far between. What is really horrific is what we discover at the end. There is a moment where Laura stops hallucinating and she fully understands what has happened (I'll avoid telling you this part, as it would ruin the movie), and that is the most horrific scene in the entire movie. There is no violence or spectacle, just understanding. All the monsters disappear and the viewer is just left with the truth. 

The movie goes on after this revelation, and stops really being a horror film. It's probably the happiest ending for a horror film I've ever seen. The last sequences of the movie vacillate between the supernatural and real life, and we are left with all the pieces tied together. Laura has finished her treasure hunt, and received her wish. 

Freud's discussion of the uncanny is also fairly interesting to consider in this movie, as well as with other horror tropes. What makes something horrific? We discussed in class how making the familiar unfamiliar is an important part of horror films. Freud's essay also delves into the concept. This is very apparent in Tomas' character in this film. He's just a young boy, nothing anyone is afraid of. But when his face is obscured with the burlap sack, suddenly we are horrified by him. I was discussing this quality while talking about this movie with a friend. I feel that the young child with a burlap sack over his face is something I felt horror about before this movie, but I have no recollection of ever seeing it before. I mentioned that I felt the same way about slender man (who is depicted as a tall man in a suit with no face), and she talked about another character that stole people's faces. In the midst of describing these characters for which we feel an absurd amount of fear and recognition, I noticed that all three of these examples have no face, or their face is obscured in some format. My theory is that this is related to Freud's belief that the unfamiliar creates such a strong feeling of repulsion in us because of its nearness to the familiar. We receive many of our emotional cues from other people's faces. The face can arguably be said to be a visual representation of our humanity. When we take just the face away from a character, this is deeply unsettling. I believe this is because we can recognize that character as human, until we get the face in which we no longer recognize or empathize with the character. Whether or not the character is a monster, we place all our preconceived notion of the inhuman on that character. Tomas is just a normal little boy, and yet we see him as a monster because of this. 

The Grotesque Reality

*Spoiler Alert*

In her essay on realistic horror, Freeland discusses that horror genre that concentrate on the terrifying and grotesque side of reality. What could be more terrifying then finding out that your next-door-neighbor is actually a serial killer. This week I watched the 2007 movie, Disturbia, which is a loose remake of Hitchcocks's Rear Window. This film follows a curious teenage boy during his summer under house arrest as he begins to learn about the world around him through binoculars. The young man, played by Shia LeBouf, and his friends become paranoid when they see their seemingly boring neighbor acting very suspiciously around the time of some murders in the area. In the original Rear Window, Jimmy Stewert and Grace Kelly are spying on a man who has potentially killed his wife, but in Disturbia, LeBouf's neighbor we discover has killed many girls all across the country. Confined to his house, LaBouf is unable to truly investigate the situation, but his two friends and his video camera begin to slowly unravel the true about this dangerous man.
I think that in horror, more than any other genre of film, the viewer is pulled into the situation and experiences of the main characters. Realist horror does this better than any other because the audience is experiencing something that they can picture themselves in their reality. Part of the realism and suspense about the film is that we only see the situation from LaBouf point of view and so are therefore don't know the whole truth of the situation. Throughout the film, LaBouf is constantly challenged on his theory's and plans. As the viewer, we slowly begin to question the situation ourselves. Are we just paranoid about the suspicious behavior or are we all in danger of diving in too deep into the life of a killer.
Everyone has those creepy neighbors and are curious about the secrets of the strangers they live around. When LaBouf first shows his friend everything that he has discovered about his neighbors, we are fascinated to see inside their very private affairs. We are attracted to knowing what we shouldn't and, like LaBouf, become almost obsessed with the hidden lives of those within his neighborhood. All goes awry when the main characters discover something that puts them in a dangerous situation, but even with the danger, something draws us in. The need and curiously for the truth takes over even with the evidence begins to work against our theories. In other horror movies the reveal focuses on the facts about the monster, but in realistic horror films, the reveal focuses on finding the monster within.
In this realistic film, there are no need special effects or suspension of disbelief in the situation because the monster is a type of person that we see over and over again in our own society. The uneasiness that the main characters and audience feel throughout the film is not about forcing ourselves into accepting the supernatural but the realization that these horrific type of events that we hear about on the news are now in our backyard. Freeland comments that “realist horror evokes real, albeit paradoxical, reactions: at the same time it is both emotionally flattening (familiar, formulaic, and predictable in showcasing violence), and disturbing (immediate, real, gruesome, random).” Within Disturbia, we are all viewing a time old story of a man killing women and the righting of wrongs, but at the same time the situations become real when the killer befriends LaBouf's mother and begins to confront the young boy about the way he's been spying on him. These intimate encounter between the main characters and the monster force the viewer into the situation of facing the grotesque realities within our society.
Horror movies cause the viewer to question their own reality and leave the theater curious about the secrets that could be hidden within their our neighborhood. One of the reasons that Horror and Thriller movies are so scary is because of the possible lasting affect on the viewer. Realistic films I think tend to stick with people the most because it is an actual possibility. Have you ever walked away from a film and had troubles falling asleep of seen a creepy man on the street and expect the worst? Even though the scary realist film focus on the righting of wrongs and for the most part justice is achieved in the end, in reality, not all of these horrific situations are brought to justice and therein lies the real fear.

Have I scene this before? (sorry, had to).

This week I watched the sci-fi horror thriller the 4th Kind.  The movie presents itself like this newer genre of horror movie that mixes “real” recordings with scenes acted out by actors.  I found the plot of the film to be similar to that of newer exorcism movies like the Last Exorcism and the Devil Inside and even akin to the Paranormal Activity series and the Blair Witch Project.  The main character of the movie Abbey Taylor, who actually is in the real recordings throughout the movie, is a psychiatrist in Nome, Alaska (A.K.A generic small town where mysterious things happen like in the Last Exorcism).  Her husband dies mysteriously before the movie and she is left with her two young children.  As she struggles with his death, she works with other patients who begin having the similar problem of waking in the middle of the night (specifically at the creepy time of 3:33 – similar to the first Paranormal Activity) and feeling fear and anxiety.  She asks one patient to meet her again as soon as possible so she can perform hypnosis (exorcism) on him to see if they can get to the root of the problem.  He starts to explain what happens to him at night, and then he recounts what he said, and finally starts to envision something terrible and reacts violently (what happens in any exorcism in the movies).  It is clear that he is unstable, but she allows him to return home.  Taylor receives a phone call early in the morning and is summoned to her client’s house.  The cops are waiting because her client is holding up his family by gunpoint.  After she fails to calm him down, he kills his wife and children and ends this murderous rampage by committing suicide.
            She performs the same exorcism on another client… whoops, I mean hypnosis (Freudian slip?).  He reacts violently as well, offering us some disgusting throat gurgling noises and vomits on top of that.  In light of the shooting, Taylor makes sure that he and his wife are prepared for anything.  Like any typical horror movie, we have a break in the action.  We are returned to the recording Taylor made a couple of days before.  It surprises us with screams and deep, mysterious, and evil sounding voices that we did not hear before.  Instead of the voices coming from a demon, we learn that the language is ancient Sumerian, the language of the first human race (or not so human as the movie would like us to believe).  Taylor is then called down to the home of her most recent client to find him in a state of panic at home.  As she attempts another hypnosis to calm him down, his body floats into the air and contorts into inhuman shapes.  He then produces the same evil voice that we had heard before.
            The final twist of the movie comes when Taylor is under house arrest for her association with these brutal occurrences.  The cop stationed in front of her house wakes up around 3:33 (coincidence?) to see a bright light above Taylor’s house.  He steps outside his vehicle and see what appears to be a UFO fly above her house.  When all of the cops arrive we learn that Taylor’s daughter has disappeared, presumably taken by the aliens in their UFO.   Everyone, of course, thinks that she is insane and they take her son away from her.  In a last ditch attempt to find her daughter, she has her friend psychiatrist preform hypnosis on her.  She has the worst reaction in the film and tries to communicate with the aliens to find her daughter.  (I will attach the scene for your viewing pleasure.  I say pleasure because I found it hysterical, but some of you may find it terrifying.)  In the end, no one really believes Taylor and the movie leaves us with little hope, another original moment of horror films.
            I realize that this is a particularly long account of what happened in the movie, but I wanted to emphasize one of the major points in Freeland’s Realist Horror.  Freeland stresses that our attraction to horror flicks does not stem from the classical approach of an interesting plot and curiosity with an unbelievable monster, but rather, “realist horror showcases spectacle, downplays plot, and plays upon serious confusions between representations of fiction and reality” (269).  By describing the plot of this movie, I was attempting to show how unoriginal the plot line is.  It follows the general form of most of the exorcism movies and more recently the Paranormal Activity films.  Generally I find those movies absolutely terrifying, so terrifying that I lie awake in bed for a couple nights trying really hard not to think about demons or exorcisms.  I do not find them frightening because the movies drive my curiosity, but rather, like Freeland says, because of spectacle.  That being said, I did not find this movie to be scary in the least.   Instead I found myself laughing at the “scary” scenes and the movie in general.  What I think this movie fails to do is create “serious confusions between representations of fiction and reality.”  The one scene that seriously attempted to do so was the murder-suicide at the beginning of the movie.  In fact, this was probably the most frightening moment of the film.  Other than that one moment, the movie never really crossed fiction and reality boundaries for me.  What I cannot tell you, on the other hand, is why I find exorcism and paranormal movies more frightening than this rendition of an alien-abduction movie.

Fear in The Omen (1976)


Personally, I am not a big fan of horror films. I get anxiety at the mere thought of watching one. Thus, I chose to watch The Omen (1976) this week (during the daylight and with the lights on!) hoping the combination of dated effects and a relatively tame storyline would limit the amount of “pop out at you” scenes for which the genre is notorious. Thankfully, this was the case.
            For those of you who have not seen the film, it is about a couple, Robert and Katherine Thorn, that adopts a baby boy, Damien, whose mother has just died from childbirth when Katherine gives birth to a stillborn child. However, this all occurs unbeknownst to Katherine who believes the child she takes home from the hospital is in fact her own. After the couple moves to London, strange events start to occur leading Robert to discover that his son is the Antichrist.
            The film is a combination of the ideas presented in Cynthia Freeland’s Realist Horror and Sigmund Freud’s The Uncanny. Last week, we discussed Noel Carroll’s The Philosophy of Horror. While this piece presents interesting, and definitely valid, concepts regarding the horror genre, its focus is more on the fictional components of horror, like monsters. As a result, we can’t use these concepts to evaluate all films within the genre because not all have monsters. Freeland uses the term “realist horror” in reference to this subset of the genre that doesn’t include monsters. Unlike Carroll’s “classical” approach, realist horror doesn’t provide us with the reassurance that what we are viewing is impossible. Instead, realist horror is “a Chicago man [that] steals corpses and skins them to make himself a suit. A drifter from Texas [who] confesses to 600 murders. A Milwaukee man [who] cannibalizes and has sex with the corpses of numerous boys he has killed” (Freedland). What makes realist horror so terrifying is that despite its seemingly fictional basis, it creates a scenario in which anyone is a potential victim. Also, while monsters do exist in realist horror, they are not the same as those defined by Carroll. Instead, monsters in realist horror are serial killers, rapists, cannibals, etc.
            In Freud’s The Uncanny, he introduces the idea of the uncanny being the opposite of what is familiar and how this in turn leads to fear. He says, “The uncanny is that class of the frightening which leads back to what is known of old and long familiar.” The example he provides to help explain this concept is a wax figure. Based on our prior knowledge of wax figures we know they are replicas of people that, like store mannequins, just stay in place and don’t move. Suppose, however, that while you are admiring one the figure winks at you, or smiles. This fear you experience is derived from the uncanny.
            The Omen, while displaying some characteristics of realist horror, deals mostly with concepts in Freud’s The Uncanny. Damien is the definition of the uncanny. We perceive and associated children with innocence and purity. However, Damien’s role in the film as the antichrist goes against everything we hold to be true and familiar when we think about children. Thus the fear we experience when watching the film is a result of the unsettling feeling we get from Damien straying from what we believe his role should be. We perceive Damien to be the monster. However, Damien’s role as the monster doesn’t exactly fit into Freeland or Carroll’s definition of a monster. Damien is not a realist horror monster because the fear he creates for the viewer is not a result of being a potential victim. Nor can Damien be considered a classical horror monster because he is not fictional being, but rather a human child. Thus Damien’s role as a monster remains somewhere in between the two concepts. However, if we view Robert Thorn’s role in the film as also that of a monster, we can say he is a realist horror monster. While Robert’s role as a monster is debatable, it can be argued that by wanting to kill his own son, regardless of who is son is, Robert is a monster.
            Overall, I thought The Omen was a great horror film. Aside from the corny music and dated effects, the film had an interesting plot and created a sense of fear without all the unnecessary (at least from my point of view!) “jump out at you and make your hair stand up” scenes that most horror films have these days. 

Poltergeist and Freud's "The Uncanny"

I enjoyed watching Poltergeist; it is well acted and it has its truly frightening parts, including a scene where a man is pictured ripping his own face off in the mirror. Only recently have I started to enjoy the horror movie genre, and in the past few years I have noticed that the movies that do the best job of scaring the living hell out of me are the ones with the least-bad (in my own eyes) quality acting and cinematography. Supernatural horror movies still have to sell me their ideas, even though I am going into them with a mostly firm disbelief in the supernatural. My curiosity, as Noel Carroll talks about extensively in his work on the horror genre, must be stimulated, and if I cannot engage in the situations that a movie poses, I will not be scared and the movie will have failed.

There is a bit of a special effects gap between Poltergeist and what is being shown in theaters today, however, although the effects look "fake" now, surely they were perceived with just as much terror as a movie like Insidious or The Fourth Kind is today. I was not as frightened during parts of Poltergeist as I would have been if the movie had been made with today's technology. For the purpose of this blog post, let us assume that I watched the movie with no historical context for special effects, and that I was extremely frightened by the on-screen action. Beyond the rush of adrenaline and beyond the movie's ability to string along my curiosity, what makes it a quality film/piece of art? I believe that the answer (for Poltergeist as well as any other well-made horror flick) lies in its ability to reveal truth.

Freud talks about the necessary quality that "uncanny" works must have in their capturing the viewer's perspective and making it one with the main character's. This caught my attention along with the part of his essay that explains the concept of "unconcealment" as it relates to horror. In "The Uncanny," Freud claims that part of what makes something uncanny, aside from it being unknown and horrifying, is its ability to reveal the concealed. It is in this way that I believe the value of horror movies reflects the value of art in general. To clarify, the relationship where substance is revealed to the viewer of the "uncanny" is similar to the relationship that a subject has with any "higher" piece of art; something must be shown to the viewer that was either formerly suppressed or unknown to him or her. That unconcealed substance, and the relationship itself, are truths. This is a Heideggarian concept which I will not go into for sake the sake of space on this blog post, but it is a concept that I firmly believe in.

Horror movies are interesting in this regard (that is, with respect to unconcealment) because they often revolve around things that are not real. Because they cannot show us the truth behind ghosts or monsters, they have to show us the truth behind our reactions to those things; therefore, the truth that a scary movie has is a self-reflective one - a scary movie shows us, among other things, how fear works in the human psyche and how the relationship between a film and it's viewer operates.

So, what is the truth that Poltergeist reveals? Well, if I had been truly scared by the movie, it could have possibly shown me something about what makes me, as an individual, afraid. What the film did do, however, was successfully create an accessible perspective (that of the parents of Carol Anne) that I could absorb while watching the movie. Looking back on the few hours that I spent viewing the film, I recall nothing out of the ordinary in my movie watching experience. That experience however, is out of the ordinary when compared to the goings-on of my everyday life. There is not one moment of my day where I sit down and participate in an activity that is remotely like watching a movie. Both my body and mind become vegetables and like slaves to the director's intentions (depending on the quality of the execution). You could tell me about the plot of Poltergeist and I would not be scared, but present it to me in a way in which I start to cognitively participate in the plot, and I become terrified. Surely there is some truth present in that relationship. This post must come to a close, but any ideas from you all would be most appreciated.

Open Water, Again (This Time With a Realist Horror Model)

Last week as a commenter, my primary critique (as well as many of yours) was that Carroll’s definition of a monster and classical model for understanding horror did not account for horror film featuring main characters like those in Psycho or Funny Games, or speak to the entire premise of films like Open Water. In her essay “Realist Horror,” Cynthia Freeland shares our concerns about the less than applicable classical theory when it comes to assessing realist horror. 
Freeland critique’s Carroll for the same reasons that we did through either posts or comments last week-- his definition of a monster is too narrow to account for realist horror films, the emphasis does not seem to be on the plot at all, and there does indeed seem to be a human interest in the spectacle of horror. 

Freeland explains that Carroll’s premise reflects Aristotle’s theory for understanding the value of tragedy. This theory breaks down to essentially three qualifications (page 264):
  1. We as viewers must acknowledge the film as imitation.
  2. We describe the construction of the film with an emphasis on plot and narrative. 
  3. We describe the emotional response to the film that the film aimed to produce. 

This creates a problem when discussing realist horror films because:
  1. Too often these films are based on, albeit sometimes loosely, real-life serial killers. Freeland cites examples of The Silence of the Lambs and Henry, both of which featured characters based on real life monsters. Clearly, these characters are not ‘impossible’ to use language from Carroll’s definition, as their real-life counterparts are just that-- real-life. She explains that these stories get just as much attention in the news as they do when they are converted for feature films, thus that there is some innate interest in monstrous displays of violence and those who commit those acts. 
  2. Freeland argues that the construction of the realist horror film is fundamentally different than that employed in tragedy and classical horror, with an emphasis not on plot but on spectacle and the aftermath of spectacle instead. 
  3. These previous two elements do not allow for the classical understanding of an aesthetic response; Freeland proposes that this is not a shortcoming of realist horror films, but that this allows for more nuanced readings into the purposes of films. She argues that deeper meanings can be read into the presentation of these violent films, citing the depiction of male violence towards women and gender identities as one example. 

Now that we have this more applicable model for understanding the subgenre of realist horror, I thought it prudent to see if the films we insisted did not fit into Carroll’s model would be better understood using Freeland’s model. Open Water, as our classmate Anna Lockhart quite succinctly put it last week, is a tale in which “the direction of the narrative is clear: couple goes diving, couple gets left behind, couple is attacked by various species within the ocean, and couple ultimately perishes.” 

In this quick summary, Anna already had pointed out two elements of the realist horror model-- first, that the ‘monsters’ of the films were various ocean predators and second, that the plot of the film is predictable (and thereby, fairly irrelevant to the success of the film). Everyone knows that the animals that attack the young couple, jellyfish and sharks, really exist; most of us have probably seen such creatures in aquarium visits. Furthermore, not only is this plot familiar and predictable, it is incredible simple. The entirety of the main action of the film falls neatly into Freeland’s proposed construction of gruesome acts ( in this case, probably the boat crew leaving them behind), the spectacle (the sharks attacking Daniel and Susan, perhaps also Susan drowning herself at the end of the film) and the aftermath (obviously, that Daniel and Susan are dead). 

To the third aspect, though, there is much to be considered. Anna also jokingly mentioned the blatant lesson of the film: don’t scuba dive, or more specifically don’t stray away from the group when scuba diving. However, we can easily sift out some of those more profound philosophical lessons that Freeland suggests from this film. I think it is possible that this film, released in 2003, speaks to humankind’s susceptibility to the natural world; in an age when we control more and more of the world around us, natural disaster and death at the hands of creatures have become increasingly terrifying as we understand just how little control we have over such things. Furthermore, I think the motives of the couple to take their vacation (to get away from their hectic lives) and the nonchalance of the fishermen who find Daniel and Susan’s camera in the stomach of the shark near the end of the film speaks to a social trend as well. 

Needless to say, having read Freeland’s article, I have a renewed appreciation for philosophy in horror films that Carroll’s article last week did not provide. 

Realist Horror in "The Following"

After reading Freeland, I decided to post about a different movie. The movie I originally chose to watch was The Possession – and there wasn’t too much to discuss in terms of realist horror that I could find. (If you identified some, please add them in your comments). Instead, I think there would be much more material to work with from the recent television series The Following. Yes, this is a TV show and although it is considered a drama thriller, I think there is much at work here in terms of horror elements that Freeland alludes to. 
Ryan Hardy (Kevin Bacon) is an FBI agent who is asked to help investigate and solve a series of murders by an ex-college professor turned serial killer, who has a crazed obsession with Edgar Allan Poe. From prison, Joe Carroll (James Purefoy) continues his “intellectual” work of murdering for the sake of art. At the scenes of each of the murders, there can be found literary evidence of Poe’s works, left by Carroll’s network of other killers. Although the show is only into its third or fourth episode, we can deduce that Hardy must play along and get one step ahead of Carroll in his literary game, filled with puzzles, blood, knives, and cut out eye-balls.
There is much to be said about this show in regards to Freeland’s arguments against the classical approach to horror. Freeland uses Henry to describe how a horror movie may create “terror and unease” without following the classical rules of having an “identification figure” or a plot that depicts any “righting of wrongs” (261). In The Following Carroll is locked up behind bars, monitored by guards 24/7. Yet the audience’s unease is constant due to the fact that Carroll’s depraved mind is conjuring scenarios that are both “promising and withholding” of the “spectacle of violence.” We know there are going to be more murders – that’s why things keep happening even though Carroll is locked up (also it’s a television show…). The point is, like in most good horror films, that half the terror is the event leading up to the spectacle of violence – its that sense of anticipation that makes for such intense sequences.
The show itself is a great representation of realist horror. A depraved college professor who knows the works of Poe so well that he aims to continue Poe’s artistic expression through his own acts of monstrous violence.
The classical approach, as Freeland says, relies on the assumption that “we can draw a distinction between artistic imitations and reality” (264). I see The Following, like realist horror for Freeland, to be “a particularly postmodern phenomenon.” The motives of Carroll blend artistic imitations with actual acts of murder to create horror. It is deduced by the FBI agents in the beginning that Carroll believes Poe’s art can only be perfected in death. Therefore, the poems represent “artistic imitation[s]” and Carroll’s murders represent a gruesome “reality.” The connection between theses two elements is what makes the show a wonderful representation of realist horror.
One could also argue that the show (and indeed realist horror) plays upon elements of the uncanny – something very real and artistic (like a poem), together with elements of bloody murder – to create horror. (Or maybe it is the other way around: the familiar element is the serial killing and the unfamiliar is the fact that poetry is the motivation for murder?) As Freeland says, “realist horror evokes real, albeit paradoxical, reactions: at the same time it is both emotionally flattening (familiar, formulaic, and predictable in showcasing violence), and disturbing (immediate, real, gruesome, random).” I think her analysis here very much applies to The Following. We have here a very predictable element of horror: a serial killer is plotting his next murder. The random and perhaps unfamiliar element is the when, where, how of the act of violence.
But perhaps my analysis of the show is a stretch. Carroll is a pretty depraved dude (his victims are all female and he cuts out their eyes), but does the show properly combine artistic imitations and reality to successfully create realist horror? What about the uncanny? Is there anything else at work here?