Stanley’s Kubrick’s The Shining, based off a Stephen King novel, does not necessarily work like a typical horror or thriller flick, even though it uses many of the same tropes and ideas. A family of three, Jack (Jack Nicholson), his wife Wendy (Shelley Duval) and his son Danny all move to take care of a remote resort for the winter. At the very beginning of the film Jack gets warned by the film’s owners about the former caretaker, Grady, who went mad and killed his family. He accepts the warning but takes the job. The whole concept of “shining” gets explained early on as a sort of telepathic power and connection, that the son and the departing chef Dick (Scatman Crothers) share. This shining gives Danny premonitions of the dead daughters of the former caretaker and later contacts Dick so that he comes help them. Around a month into the stay, Jack’s mental stability begins to quickly vanish. He lacks sleep and acts irritable as he deals with writer’s block. After going into room 237, he interacts with several different supernatural apparitions, culminating in talking to the old caretaker who convinces Jack to “correct” his family. This is when Jack fully goes mad, seeking out his family to kill them, eventually killing Dick but getting lost in the maze while his wife and child survive.
From the very beginning we know the main story, that Jack will go mad. Like most films in this genre there is a warning of the danger to come at the start of the story. But even though we know the what, we still desire the how and especially the why. The music sets the tone, even early in the movie there is suspenseful music where nothing happens, already making you look around every corner.
The intriguing aspect of this movie is that the horror comes from within. Isolation from the outside world is a common aspect of all horror and thriller films, a theme that makes sense because we are more easily scared in smaller groups or alone. A haunted place, supernatural events, are also aspects that follow along with the common theme. But with many horror films it is an outside monster that scares and intrigues us, a demon or a Frankenstein. In this film, you see Jack throughout the movie and have some knowledge of him. It is Jack who attempts to kill his own family, not an outside horror. He seems influenced by the place and supernatural beings but they only seem to exacerbate a madness already there, not create it. It gets revealed he had already hurt Danny in a drunken fit, a precursor of the violence he seeks later. And Jack had already been writing the same ominous phrase “all work and no play makes Jack a dull boy” even before we know about him seeing anything supernatural.
So does that madness from within make this movie scarier? It certainly brings a different type of psychological fright. In his essay “The Paradox of Horror”, Noel Carroll says that we are drawn to horror because of basic curiosity of the other. But the paradox of such attraction is that while we want to know the other, because it is other it naturally repels and disgusts us. “Art-horror is the price we are willing to pay for the revelation of that which is impossible and unknown, of that which violates our conceptual schema” (175). In some sense this remains true in The Shining but it is not obvious as some monster or demon that we desire to discover. Instead it is the place and the madness that frighten but intrigue us. Why can Danny “shine”? Who or what is “Tony”, Danny’s friend he telepathically interacts with? How can Danny then Jack then Wendy interact with the apparitions? Did Jack already have the seeds of madness or did the place just plant them?
We are intrigued by these questions, by the supernatural, but our horror and disgust comes from something that is not necessarily even supernatural. The sad fact is such crimes as Grady’s and the one Jack tries to commit do occur. We cannot understand why, and that where the real horror and disgust but also the fascination with Jack’s madness come into play. It is more real, closer to home. Most people do not actually believe in demons affecting the world or Frankenstein’s roaming the earth but we do know these crimes exist. In the end, The Shining gives us a picture of many things we are curious about and also something something that scares us, partially because of its actual possibility.
