Showing posts with label Mind and Metaphysics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mind and Metaphysics. Show all posts

Saturday, January 19, 2013

Constructing Identity for Truman Burbank

Several of my classmates have already unpacked the relevant connections between Truman's Burbank's experience as he realizes that his whole life has been a facade for the sake of television entertainment and the realizations Descartes explores in his Second Meditation. Indeed, I am sure that the character Truman Burbank struggles with some of the same subjects Descartes is writing on-- primarily, a human's ability to discern what is real and what is not.  

Instead of discussing the experience of reality, I would like to address the characters' experience with identity in this film. 

At the very beginning of the film, the actress Hannah Gill is giving an interview statement about her 'double life.' She says, "For me there is no difference between private life and public life. My life is my life, it's the Truman show." In his essay “Of Identity and Diversity,” philosopher John Locke writes about identity, “This also shews wherein in Identity of the same Man consists; viz. in nothing by a participation of the same continued Life, by constantly fleeting particles of matter, in succession vitally united to the same organized Body.” The supporting characters of the Truman show, particularly the more central characters like Meryl, Marlon and Truman’s mother, have a unique experience of identity. Their fulltime role has surpassed the nature of a role into the imitation of an identity; indeed, all acting to an extent is this taking on of a false identity. The concept of The Truman Show, however, has elevated this imitation to a level of devotion to a false identity beyond that of normal pretense-- the height of this example being in my opinion when director Christof suggests that there is an on screen conception in the future plans for the show. Ultimately actress Hannah leaves her role as Truman’s wife Meryl, revealing that there are limitations to an individual’s ability to commit to an identity that is not their own. 

So, what does this element of Locke’s understanding of identity mean for Truman at the end of the film? The action of the film ends with Truman exiting the set that has been his world since birth and Sylvia seemingly running to meet up with him-- an ending which I feel suggests hope for the establishment of a life post-Truman Show for our protagonist. However, “if the Identity of the same Man consists in nothing but a participation of the same continued Life,” what will Truman’s new identity look like? I think it can be said for certain that Truman’s existing identity has already begun to be challenged throughout his realization that his world was a facade. In the opening moments of the film, show creator Christof says, “There is nothing fake about Truman himself.” What Christof means, of course, is to identify what precisely is so appealing about the television program. Because Truman does not know he is being filmed or that his life is being monitored and controlled, he does not limit his actions in accordance with that knowledge; he has no extraordinary inhibitions or intentionally wild behaviors that are common features of “reality” television in our own society. After Truman has abandoned his false life, however, I wonder if Truman too would agree that there was nothing false about his identity. A brief example-- are a person’s fears a part of their identity? Truman’s fear of open water was constructed as a plot point by the show creator; does this undermine the truth of this part of Truman’s identity? 

Naturally, this discussion of humankind’s autonomy works well when thinking about the nature of humans’ interaction with deities and religion. If Christof’s decision to create a situation in which Truman will almost certainly fear open water instills in Truman a fear that is falsely part of his identity, can anything that is beyond the control of us as humans be considered a part of shaping our identity? By this, I mean to speak directly to the question of the level of direct control that God has in the lives of humans (using the modern Western Abrahamic understanding of God). I feel that the situations are comparable; the film features a substantial use of Western imagery to underscore that Christof is playing God in this situation. 

This subject has raised more questions about the nature of exterior forces in shaping our identity than perhaps it has answered today. If Identity is in fact constructed of all the elements discussed in John Locke’s essay, there are many factors of which we must take inventory to truly understand ourselves. Lucky for us, we will hopefully have one series of moments to account for, unlike Truman who, I suppose after the end of the film, must in a sense begin completely anew. 

Friday, January 18, 2013

The Complexities of Contemplation


Darren Aronofsky’s Pi thrusts you into the dark and fixated mind of Max Cohen. Max’s world (portrayed by Aronofsky in solely black and white) is consumed by obsessive thoughts of numbers and patterns. More precisely, Max believes that through the rigorous analysis of Pi and the Golden Ratio, patterns can be found in nature which will ultimately allow mankind to decode and predict the natural world. Almost every second of Max’s days are spent hysterically typing lines of code into his homemade supercomputer in hopes of discovering the numerical. According to Max:

      1. Mathematics is the language of nature.
      2. Everything around can be represented and understood by numbers.
      3. If you graph the numbers of any system, patterns emerge.
            4.Therefore, there are patterns everywhere in nature.

There is never a calm moment in Max’s world, and we feel this crippling anxiety throughout the entirety of the movie. The neurotic need to decode the world is literally eroding Max’s (and the viewer’s) sanity. As every second passes, it seems as if Max is spiraling further and further away from reality. The stress of living a life consumed by racing thoughts and numbers constantly triggers severe panic attacks which Max must helplessly and painfully endure. The tragic irony of Max’s desire to comprehend the natural world paired with his imminent mental collapse signifies a philosophical conundrum: is man capable of fully understanding the world in which we live in? And, if that is even possible, is man capable of living with the breadth and weight of that knowledge? 

It’s easy to see some of Rene Descartes’ qualities in Max Cohen. Descartes, like Max, felt an immense desire to comprehend the natural world through his own understanding. Descartes begins his Second Meditation by admitting that, “the Meditation of yesterday has filled [his] mind with so many doubts, that it is no longer in [his] power to forget them.” Like Max, it appears that Descartes’ furious contemplation and questioning has developed into an insatiable desire for understanding. Both men see it fit to discard all that is generally taken to be irrefutably true and start from the bottom up. Descartes abandons the comforting belief that all that we are surrounded by is true and real, and asserts that “body, figure, extension, motion, and place are merely fictions of [his] mind.” Now, nothing exists but the mind and its ability to think. Therefore, we can deduce mankind into “thinking things.” However, being thinking things begs an extension of that definition. Thinking things are capable of doubting, understanding, affirming, denying, willing, refusing, imagining, and perceiving—the capacities of the mind are seemingly endless, yet also prone to error. 
When an individual is presented with a physical stimulus, he or she comes to understand it in two ways. The first is through sensual perception—touch, smell, sound, etc. But this yields an inevitable understanding through contemplation. Both means have the potential to be correct and incorrect, depending on the scenario, yet it is apparent that the mind will ultimately allow us to fully understand more than our senses will. This is so because, according to Descartes, the authenticity of the physical world is still not sure while we can be sure that we are cognitive and contemplative beings—while we cannot always be sure of the contents of our minds, we can be sure that we are capable, at least, of thinking.

This is where I find Max’s story to be so terribly tragic. His neurotic need to understand this physical world ultimately destroyed his mind. The final scenes of the movie show Max discovering what could potentially be the magic number sequence. Seconds after, Max suddenly appears in what can be construed in an alternate reality—a reality devoid of the stress and mania that had plagued every second of Max’s life. Is this wholesome understanding? Is this life, in its purest and realest form?
He and the viewer are finally at peace, albeit for only a few short seconds. Max is thrust back into his tiny apartment, and makes his way into the bathroom. He produces a drill, which Max turns on and slowly moves towards the part of his skull which is represented in phrenology as the mathematical portion of his brain. He slowly drills into brain and the scene ends. 



Moments later, we see Max in a park sitting peacefully in a bench. This is not the anxious Max we had been forced to watch throughout the movie. A little girl who was well acquainted with Max’s genius asks him a difficult math problem. Max smiles and replies that he does not know. It seems that he has rid himself of his genius and is pleasantly ignorant to the intricacies which had made him a prisoner to his own mind.
Are we better off ignorant? Are the complexities of life too convoluted for human understanding? Regardless, it seems to be a human characteristic to question the world around us in order to give both life and ourselves meaning.

Identity and Perception in The Prestige


I had seen The Prestige before it was assigned this week, but I had never re-watched it, and this is certainly a film that demands a re-watch.

I found Renee Descartes’ Second Meditation incredibly relevant to this film. Descartes begins this paper by questioning the nature of reality. What, of what we observe in our world and what of what we posit from these observations can be held as irrefutable fact? Decartes uses this question to argue that the mind is more readily understandable than the body. This must be true because the physical world can only explained “according to the notions that I had then formed of it” (134).

The subordination of physical reality to the fallible perception of the mind is a central them in The Prestige. The magic performed in throughout the movie is, as both the film’s and the act’s audience are aware, only illusion. A particularly philosophically relevant part of the movie is a line spoken by Cutter, which both opens and ends the movie: “Now you're looking for the secret... but you won't find it, because of course you're not really looking. You don't really want to know. You want to be fooled.” Searching for the secret behind the illusion is an admittance of the fallibility of our perception. Our senses were fooled, and this leads to the unsettling realization that physical reality, which strikes as factual is actually a matter of our perception, and, as such, is difficult to know in fact.

As Angier says near the end of the movie, “The audience knows the truth: the world is simple. It's miserable, solid all the way through. But if you could fool them, even for a second, then you can make them wonder, and then you... then you got to see something really special...” The notion of magic seems like it is the hope or the acceptance that a mysterious and unknowable power works on plane invisible to us, but in a way, the idea of magic is also an undeserved affirmation of our own sensory expertise. In invoking the idea that there is a force beyond our senses, magic is also claiming that our senses are infallible at perceiving what is presented to them. According to this idea, magic is not illusion that capitalizes on our ability to misperceive what is right in front of us, but merely an action that operates on a plane separate from human senses.

The question of identity, especially in terms of our Locke reading, Of Identity and Diversity, also had significant bearing in The Prestige. In the introduction of Of Identity Locke states that it is “impossible for two things of the same kind to be or exist in the same instant, in the very same place; or one and the same thing in different places. All conflict within The Prestige is rooted in a crisis of identity wherein two men occupy a single identity. The Borden brothers live their life as if they were the same man, but the tug of their independent identities tears their life and those of the ones they love apart. Each brother is in love with a different woman, but the inconsistent affections of Alfred Borden lead to the loss of love for each of the brothers. Their effort to present a single identity to the world is the kind of sacrifice Borden repeatedly claims to be the only possible source of any great trick.

In the final iteration of the trick Angier actually clones himself, an act that stresses the notion of identity to its limit. Every performance he is both brought in to the world and taken from it. If we take our brief view of his first experience with the machine, where he shoots his double, then the Angier that drowns is the original one and the Angier that is the Prestige is technically the clone. And yet, he reveals his fear: “Would I be the man in the box or the prestige?” showing us that he acknowledged a difference between the two Angiers, but every night Angier was the Prestige, suggesting that he and his clone were perfectly identical in mind, body, experience, consciousness ( Which, like Descartes, Locke argues that identity is rooted in the consciousness of our being, in fact the tenth section of his essay is tilted “Consciousness makes personal identity” (9-10)). He never recognized himself as the one in the box, although it seems that was almost certainly his original self. At the moment of the act’s crescendo, Angier and his second are almost certainly of the same identity, but every passing second separates them through their experience. If the drowned Angier were allowed to live he would certainly be unable to maintain a shared identity with his twin, experience would change them from each other.

Where Is My Mind?


 How can we be so sure that while reading this blog post, you are in your waking life? Could it be possible that in your dream state you happen to come to a computer and log on to view your philosophy and film blog? As I am sure you all are aware, Descartes begins a similar series of doubts (well, he does not know of computers or blogs, but he is still curious to know whether or not he is in fact in a dream), and shows that this doubt is a serious question for all of philosophy to answer.
            In the 1984 film Dreamscape, starring Dennis Quaid as the psychic Alex Gardner and Max von Sydow as the Doctor Paul Novotny and Christopher Plummer as Bob Blair, a government agent with ulterior motives. In the film, Doctor Paul Novotny contacts Alex Gardner in order to help participate in a new scientific study about dreams and the ways of accessing them. Alex is of course reluctant to join for he has routinely tried to hide his psychic abilities in order to avoid raising suspicion for himself. Eventually Alex gives in to Doctor Novotny and joins the experiment. Due to his psychic abilities, Alex is able to “enter” the dream of another human being, provided that the human being has entered REM mode and Alex has conditioned his body to match his heart’s BPM with the victim.
            Because of this distortion of reality, the film Dreamscape brings about an interesting perspective on the material nature of the body, and the possible materiality of the human mind. This in turn is a response to Descartes’ notions of the dualistic nature of mind and body, answering to Descartes musings that yes, the mind is of material substance, and yes, this substance can be exploited and explored provided there is someone who contains telekinetic and psychic powers of the mind. This is an interesting inference, not only for the sake of the film Dreamscape, but so much so that in any case there is a person who proclaims to be a psychic, or can bend spoons with their minds must deny that there is an immaterial mind. If this were not the case, how on earth can an immaterial mind “read” another immaterial mind? Is it by going through the ethereal space? Or is it because the minds are alike the psychic can “find” another mind?
            While the film does not try to answer these questions, it cannot help but raise even more questions, specifically with each scene in which Alex “enters” another person’s dream. Through each sequence, there is a distorted tunnel that is shown through different substances, colors, as well as environments. For the neurotic husband, his dream is an erotic red that billows and bellows the sounds of a female, while a terrified boy being eaten away by his nightmares has a tunnel that is in shades, has a violent soundscape full of clanging and lightning, and every other person Alex enters also has a unique and different tunnel. This film shows that each person has a unique substance, a different tunnel that can help him or her be recognized. Is this not another way of understanding Locke’s Of Identity and Diversity?  For a “thinking intelligent Being, that has reason and reflection” can in fact be recognized as such by Alex or any other Psychic. For each mind Alex enters, he is in fact entering another person’s consciousness and reflection. Alex can understand the minds around him, and can in fact perceive another person’s identity. If it is possible for Alex to enter another person’s mind, that person must also exist, for without existence, Alex would have nothing to enter into. The mind as itself tries to lock itself away from the outside world, but Alex, and any other psychic in our world, can perceive the inner workings of the mind.
            A final musing over the film Dreamscape is the notion that if a person is killed in a dream by a psychic (I am assuming that the figments of a person’s mind cannot kill that particular person, but only a psychic who infiltrates the mind and contains a unique substance to itself can possibly kill the mind), that person is in fact killed in real life. If this is the case, then this would mean that the mind’s own physicality takes such precedence over the body, that it is one of the few characteristics of a person that is a necessity. Without the mind, a person is a corpse.
            Through all of the film, a cheesy story line and amusing action sequences take place, but the questions and implications the film raise make it worth a viewing.

Mentally Divergent


Locke discusses the common human occasion of our minds thinking about the being of objects and bodies in the present state of space and time. No doubt many of us have wondered at some point or another if an object that appears in front of us also exists in some distant galaxy. We are quick to accept (and love) this idea of the earth floating in some galaxy, surrounded by an endless universe. This idea is so popular in our minds because it gives our imaginations very few limits. Knowing that we are just one civilization existing in an indefinite space gives reason to believe that anything could be happening in some distant galaxy light years away. It gives people ideas, such as having an identical twin of oneself in some other dimension or what have you. 

Locke states that, according to the principium Individuationis, it is impossible for a single object (or any particle of matter) to exist beside itself. That is, an object is subject to its own individuality and therefore exists, and “cannot exist in different times or indifferent places” (Fumerton and Jeske, 193). Locke says that the fact that we have notions and names of identity and diversity for objects bounds them to a certain sort of law explaining that there can not be duplicates of objects. The objects would have to be “one and the same.” Without these defined limits, Locke says that we would not be able to distinguish any objects or substances “or anything else from one another” (192). 


In 12 Monkeys, a film documenting the life of a convict time traveler in the late twentieth century, James Cole travels back to the past (which the audience identifies as the present, making where he came from the future). We of course know that time travel is a hypothetical rendition of alternate dimensions, featuring complex science fiction theories of particulate matter and light. However, Locke would say that time traveling is impossible for a different reason. That is, due to the principles upon which objects and bodies exist, that there can only be one of something in time and place, traveling back in time to see oneself younger would be impossible. As Locke says, “A colt grown up to a horse, sometimes fat, sometimes lean, is all the while the same horse” (193).

Therefore, according to Locke, while one can see a picture of himself in a photograph (which is itself its own object also), he can not see another body of himself existing because his identity and “bodyness” can only exist in one place and one time. His body has been determined to a particular time and place.

But Descartes asks “How can we know if anything is true? (Which is an entirely separate question from “How can anything be true?”) For if he really means that “there is really nothing easier to know than my mind,” and his mind is trusted by himself, than anything that he deems true in his trusted mind would make it true to him. For Descartes, thinking is truth because thinking justifies existence. However, according to his descriptions of the immortal and the soul, Hume states that “the immaterial substance can lose its memory or consciousness” (230). Would this mind, affected by memory loss or damage, be any more unreliable for discovering truth? It would of course still be the same mind, as Locke would put it, but would it be capable of distinguishing the truth as it had formerly done?

In 12 Monkeys the interesting phrase “mentally divergent” is used to describe a state of mind. What does this mean? The audience comes to grasp a sort of understanding by the end of the film. A man in the beginning uses the phrase to describe a sort of psychosis or a state of mind in which he is. It is interesting to hear such a phrase because the film does a nice job of tying this idea in with time travel. Cole travels back in time to warn the human race, but his cries are only met with disbelief, restraining trips to a mental institution, and violent interactions with law enforcement. He even begins to question his own sanity. The psychiatrist with whom Cole flees mentions that she has seen him before, but at first still thinks him insane. Later in the film we witness a sort of role reversal, wherein she must keep him going after Cole breaks down and begins saying that he is actually mentally ill. Has she only seen him in a dream, or has this “mentally divergent” syndrome allowed her to come across him in another time?

The Nature of Truth and Identity



 In the film The Prestige, the very nature of truth and identity are playfully toyed with at the expense of the audience for the direct purpose of demonstrating the complicated nature which both of these concepts entail. Who both of the main characters are is a question that is constantly thrown into question until the very end. At the very beginning, however, the watcher is instructed indirectly by Cutter through his dialogue with Borden’s daughter when he tells her to “Watch closely”. As Descartes points out throughout his Mediations, the senses can deceive and are not completely reliable for the discovery of the true nature of the world.
            In his Disappearing Man illusion, Borden uses his twin brother to deceive the audience into believing that he has defied physics and been transported through space and time to another location on the other side of the stage. As Locke states in “Of Identity and Diversity”, two things cannot be in the same place at once and it follows then that one thing cannot be in two places at once. Throughout the film, Angier is obsessed with discovering the secret of this illusion and is convinced that it cannot be as simple as a double. These magicians exist as a sort of paradox, they are meant to, by definition, conceal the truth from the audience, but they are completely obsessed with knowing the truth themselves. What the truth is, however, is hidden to the point where the audience is forced to question whether or not these magicians even truly know the truth.
            A very cynical world view is expressed twice in the movie that the world is a horrible place. Angier’s double asserts that if everyone knew as much about the world as he did that they would be drunk all the time as well. At the end, while Angier is dying from a gunshot wound inflicted by Borden, he expresses a similar view that the world is a horrible place and that everyone knows it, but it is their job as a magician to attempt to fool them. It is not just that the audience is fooled however; it is that they want to be fooled. The truth is not what they want, because according to Angier they already know it and are constantly engaging in an illusion themselves.
Robert Angier, at the beginning of the movie, seems quite happy with his life until his wife’s untimely death. His very identity is thrown into question at this point. Borden’s identity, however, is kept a mystery throughout the entire film. But are these characters who they pretend to be? Are they who people think they are? Or are they something completely different altogether? Borden states that he and his brother lived only half a life and that this was enough for them, but not enough for their spouses. Although Angier states that the entirety of the world knows that the world is horrid and awful and wish to be deceived, Sarah Borden and Olivia Wenscombe as a case study show that constant deception leads to horrible consequences. Although Angier claims that everyone deceives themselves, when it is someone else doing the deceiving suddenly this does not lead to the result that Angier claims it does. Sarah knows that she is being lied to and is constantly led to question everything about her entire existence because nothing is as it seems on the surface level. Olivia calls Borden cold and it would require a high level of the inhuman quality which she asserts he has to do all of the things that he did.
One is left with the feeling that Borden has really been misunderstood throughout the entirety of the movie and is really the “good guy” but I am forced to question whether or not there is a “good guy” besides possibly Cutter. This one man seems to have knowledge on a par with both Borden and Angier, but keeps his humanity. Cutter, however, is an older man and, as he regularly states, obsession is for the young, implying that he has not always been so. This leads to another slightly deeper question into whether or not it is possible to live a moral life or if it is only possible to live the least immoral life possible. One of the Bordens, at least, is able to get through the obsession of his youth and discover what is important in his life—his daughter. But the questions are left hanging. What defines us? Is it what we do, who we think we are, what people think of us, or something else altogether? What is the truth? Is the truth good, bad, or neither?